Best insurance company marketing tips to attract clients

Insurance Company Marketing Tips to Get More Clients Fast

Are you wondering how you’ll grow your insurance business with so many insurance companies already in the industry? Maybe you worry that you can’t stand out amongst the competition because you have nothing special to offer.

Spoiler alert: you do!

The key is knowing the top insurance marketing ideas to get the organic traffic you desire and to end the need to spend money buying leads constantly.

Keep reading to learn the successful marketing tips for insurance companies to help your insurance agency grow.

Why Insurance Marketing Tips Are Important

Thanks to the internet, clients can find insurance agents anywhere, not just in their local area. That’s why knowing all the best marketing strategies are crucial so you can set yourself apart from the other businesses and be one of the top insurance agencies for your niche. Using as many digital marketing tactics as possible gives you a greater chance of attracting new clients.

39 Best Insurance Company Marketing Tips

Insurance Marketing Tips

You don’t want to be just any insurance agency. Your insurance marketing ideas should show target clients you are above the competition. It should tell them why they should choose you over anyone else.

Here’s what to consider when creating a digital marketing plan for your insurance agency.

1. Solidify Your Target Audience

As an insurance agent, you likely cater to a specific audience, and your insurance marketing efforts should portray it. For example, it wouldn’t do you any good to market to people looking for health insurance when you sell mostly auto insurance.

To avoid wasted time and money, narrow down who you want to focus on or who could best use your insurance products. This is the audience you want to focus your insurance marketing strategies on because they are potential customers who would go to another firm if they didn’t come to you.

2. Build Your Brand Strategy and Identity

It’s important to have a brand for customers to recognize no matter where they find you, whether it’s your insurance website, social media marketing posts, or a flyer. Your logo, colors, and all other branding details must remain consistent across the board.

Think about McDonalds. You could likely spot the golden arches anywhere and immediately know what they stand for; that’s what you want for your brand. When your audience sees your branding, you want them to be able to recognize that it’s you, through your insurance marketing strategy.

3. Identify Your Short and Long-term Goals

Effective marketing strategies for insurance require you to identify your short and long-term goals. To build the insurance business of your dreams, consider following the SMART goals framework.

  • Specific: Make your goals as specific as possible. For example, don’t say, ‘I want more insurance leads.’ Of course you do, as does every other insurance agency in existence. Instead, give yourself deadlines and put numbers to your goals, such as ‘I want 20 new clients per month,’ or whatever is realistic for your business.
  • Measurable: When you make your goals specific, they can also be measured. Using our example from above, you can measure your progress by seeing how close you are to your 20 new clients per month.
  • Attainable: Don’t get crazy with your goals. It’s a good idea to dream big, especially in the insurance industry, but make your goals attainable. You can always level up after reaching your initial goals but don’t make them so far-fetched that you miss your chance to grow your insurance business.
  • Relevant: Make your goals relevant to your business by stating specifics, such as the type of potential customers you want to attract. For example, I want to add 20 young families to my clientele. Make your statements specific to what your business offers.
  • Time-bound: Give each goal a deadline. It’s okay if you don’t reach it and need to adjust, but it lights a fire under your team to reach the goal rather than being disappointed.

4. Ensure Your Offers and Services Are Clear and Concise

Insurance is overwhelming for the average person, so anything that would make them more confused will turn them away from your business. Your offers must be clear and concise, letting your ideal customer base know exactly what you offer.

For example, if you cater to young families, your offers should clearly state that so entrepreneurs don’t overlook your company as a possibility because they don’t think you offer what they need.

5. Conduct a Competitor Analysis

Chances are you aren’t one of the only insurance agencies in the area, so doing a competitor analysis will help you understand what you’re up against. This isn’t to say that you should copy your competitors. Instead, you should see what they do well and what they don’t and then see how you can do even better.

The key is to do one better than your competitors, a.k .a. fill a void they aren’t filling, so you get more prospective clients than your competitors. To do this, you should:

  • Evaluate the keywords they use
  • Use and rate their website, determining what’s missing that your target audience may want
  • Consider their pricing and offers
  • Look for any shortcomings that you could fill
  • Determine what marketing strategies they use

6. Nail Down Your Marketing Budget

Getting carried away with paid marketing ideas is easy, but that isn’t always necessary. The key is to get as much organic traffic as possible, so nailing down your marketing campaign budget is key. When you know how much you have to spend, you can carefully spread it out in the different areas.

7. Create a Mobile-Friendly Website

Of course, the best digital insurance marketing strategies require a solid website, but focusing only on how it looks online is a mistake. You must have a mobile-friendly website, too, as many people check websites on their phones when making important decisions, such as which insurance agent to consider. A website that isn’t mobile-friendly will turn away potential customers. A mobile-friendly website also increases your visibility, brand identity, and lead-generation capabilities.

8. Optimize for SEO

One of the most important company marketing points is to optimize for SEO for insurance companies or search engine optimization. This is what makes your website visible to your prospective customers and how you increase your business.

When you optimize for SEO, you do the following:

  • Do keyword research: Using the right keywords is the best way to reach potential customers. You want to use words they use when actively searching so you come up in the top few search results, increasing the chances of clients clicking your website to learn more.
  • Create an SEO strategy: Your SEO strategy is unique to your business. No two companies have the same strategy; you want to beat your competitors! Your marketing strategies for insurance must include on-page and off-page SEO tactics, including local SEO, to attract clients in your area.
  • Website optimization: Slapping together a website doesn’t mean your customers will find you. You won’t get the views you anticipated without proper keyword usage or a good content marketing strategy.

9. Start a Blog

You might not think anyone would read a blog from someone in the insurance industry, but this is a key factor in your search engine optimization! Google looks for regular updates, and what better way to do it than with a blog? Content marketing for insurance companies is key to building your online reputation.

When you have a blog about insurance concepts and relevant content, you show yourself as an authority in the industry. Your blog posts can include:

  • Helpful tips
  • Definitions of difficult topics
  • Comments about the latest insurance industry news

10. Send Regular Email Newsletters

Email marketing is a great way to reach your target audience and provide value. An email marketing campaign is another way to build your online reputation by providing your audience with news, tips, and promotions.

The difference between email marketing and content marketing is that you can get more personal with your client base, making them feel as if your email was specifically for them and not your entire audience. Making this a consistent part of your marketing efforts can help you build a larger audience.

11. Network With Other Professionals

Don’t be afraid to network with professionals in and outside the industry at networking events or anywhere else. Some key players include financial advisors, bankers, attorneys, and business owners. Think of anyone in the area that comes into contact with people who might need your services.

Let other professionals know what you do and what you specialize in. Give them an idea of who you cater to and how you can help them, and let them see how helpful your insurance company can be in helping their clients. The key is to build relationships to get referrals from other small businesses.

12. Print and Direct Mail Marketing Is Still Helpful

Despite all the talk about digital marketing, there are other marketing plans too, such as print and direct mail marketing. You want to focus on local marketing when targeting a particular geographic location to get more clients. Again, ensure your printed and direct mail marketing has the same branding as your digital marketing to keep a cohesive front.

13. Sponsor Local or National Events

Attending local events is one of the best ways to get your name out in the community. You can sponsor a local sports team, host a booth at a trade exhibition, or be a speaker at local conferences. The key is to share your expertise and show that you care about the community. This is a great networking event without feeling like one. You showcase your authority in the industry and let others see you are the expert.

14. Get Involved in the Community

Getting involved in the community doesn’t mean only providing your insurance agency expertise. Sometimes, it means getting your hands dirty and volunteering to make the community a better place to show that are not just insurance agents. Showing your community that you care gives potential customers a better idea of what you stand for and that it’s not just to make money.

15. Provide Helpful and Informative Downloads

Showcasing yourself as a leader in the industry is easy when you provide your audience with helpful and informative downloads. These freebies could be a quick PDF, chart, ebook, or video that gives potential customers valuable insights. The more education you provide, the more you show your audience that you care and aren’t just trying to get more leads.

This lead generation strategy helps you get a larger list of potential clients you can continually market to. The more you engage with your audience and nurture them, the more likely they will become paying clients.

16. Code Interactive Website Tools

Interactive website tools keep your audience engaged and encourage more website visitors. Think of the tools your audience would use the most and add them to your website as a part of your digital marketing strategy.

While the ideal goal is to have your audience talk to you in person to close the deal, you want to provide them with as many helpful tools as possible so they remember your company over others when deciding who to use.

17. Encourage Referrals

Using your past clients to help you get more leads can be an effective insurance marketing strategy. Encourage your clients to pass your name along to those they know who could use your services. There’s no higher compliment a client can pay you than providing client referrals or testimonials to let others know of your services.

You can politely ask that they send referrals your way or even make them your referral partners and offer incentives to do so, such as a small gift card or gift in exchange for a successful referral.

18. Implement a System for Requesting Reviews

Reviews are an important part of your insurance marketing ideas. While it might feel awkward to ask for reviews, they are integral to your business! If you haven’t claimed your Google business profile yet, use this free resource. Your Google My Business page is a great way to ask for client testimonials from past clients to show future customers what you offer.

19. Respond to Reviews

Every time you receive a review, take the time to respond to it. Thank the customer personally. This not only makes your past clients feel warm and fuzzy, but it shows potential clients how much you care about your clientele. It proves that you treat your customers as people, not just another number.

20. Record Company Videos

Video marketing is a key component of your marketing techniques. Implementing keywords in your videos and providing valuable content can help you rank higher in the search engines. You can post videos to YouTube, your website, or your social media platforms to increase your views and get new customers.

21. Add Chat to Your Website

Customers today like instant gratification. They want answers as quickly as possible and don’t want to wait for you to return a voicemail or answer an email. Online chat allows instant access to your business and is a great way to grab the potential client’s attention while they are strongly considering finding an insurance business.

22. Invest in Marketing Automation

You might think all these marketing tips will take up too much of your time, but investing in marketing automation is the key to ‘setting it and forgetting it.’ Of course, this doesn’t mean your marketing efforts are ever put on the back burner. However, setting certain tasks up to be automatically carried out can alleviate your stress and ensure your marketing plans are carried out.

23. Optimize Your Social Media Profiles

Take full advantage of social media platforms by creating optimized social media profiles. Stick to the same branding, but anyone who visits your profile should immediately recognize what you do and offer in your social media marketing. It should be apparent that you are an insurance agency and the type of clientele you cater to so that you get the right types of leads from your social media presence.

24. Livestream on Social Media for Q&A

Social media sites are free; you should take full advantage of them! Social media pages are a great avenue for live videos where you host Q&As, providing your audience with free answers and knowledge so they can make informed decisions about their insurance needs. Providing these clips is a great way to alleviate the stress clients feel about talking to professionals, allowing them to get their questions answered easily.

25. Host a Webinar or Seminar

Seminars or online seminars, called webinars, are also a great way to use your marketing resources. Let your audience hear you talk about important topics to help build trust in your business. As you show your expertise, it’s much easier for your audience to consider you for their insurance agent needs versus another company.

26. Land Speaking Gigs

You may find opportunities to speak at other events as you network with other business professionals. You don’t always have to be the event’s host to be the speaker. As you build more client relationships and show your expertise, more businesses may look to you for your insurance policies experience and want you to speak at their engagements.

27. Get Press Coverage

Press coverage is easier to get than most people realize, especially with the internet and social media today. Try to get recognized for your awards, community service, or insurance services. Most people will lean toward the companies that get good press when they need someone they can trust, so the more you show up in the press, the better.

28. Build Authority With Guest Posts

Guest posts act as digital speaking engagements, letting you share expertise with new audiences. By using strong copywriting, these posts highlight your authority and connect with readers on a platform they already trust. This strategic content helps attract potential clients and reinforces your credibility in the industry.

29. Participate in Podcast Interviews

Podcast interviews are another form of ‘press,’ just not in print or video. No one will see your face when you do a podcast interview, but they will hear what you have to offer and form their own opinion of your company based on what you share. This is a great way to get in front of a larger audience and have more people learn about what you offer.

30. Stay Active on Insurance Forums and Facebook Groups

Online forums are a great way to stay engaged with your target market. They offer a way to get personal and discuss concerns with potential clients where they are comfortable. You can help keep the record straight about insurance companies, provide tips, and offer consultations to help people in the group with their tax and insurance needs.

31. Run a Giveaway

Running a giveaway is a great way to get more attention. Consider it a part of your marketing budget and run a small giveaway that attracts attention and helps you get more insurance leads. Of course, you’ll ask for the contact information of anyone who enters, allowing you access to your audience in the future.

32. Apply for Local Awards

Pay attention to any local awards your community offers, and apply for them. The more ‘good press’ you get, the easier it is to build a larger audience. Your awards could be for your insurance business and what you offer or even for doing good within the community.

33. Sign Up for Marketing Directories

Get your name on as many marketing directories as possible, especially if they are free, like Clutch. Be sure to complete your profile on the directories as much as possible, giving your audience as much information as possible about your business to encourage them to contact you when they need insurance agents.

34. Initiate Co-Marketing and Joint Ventures

Consider combining your marketing ideas and efforts if you have a company you work well with and wouldn’t mind swapping ideas for a marketing plan. This helps increase your market share and profits by keeping costs down and playing off one another’s ideas to maximize your marketing strategy.

35. Experiment With Paid Advertising

You may consider paid ads if you’ve exhausted all organic marketing ideas and use them consistently. We caution you not to go overboard with them as they often don’t provide the same results as organic marketing strategies, but they can be a good complement when you want to fill in with more leads.

36. Try Influencer Marketing

You might not think of influencers when you think about marketing for insurance companies, but it can be a solid strategy for building your clientele. Influencers who talk about using your company and how you helped them or who boast about your services may help get your name in front of audiences that otherwise may never have known you.

37. Optimize Your Marketing and Sales Team Communication

Your marketing and sales team must work together. Your marketing team identifies leads, and your sales team is responsible for following up with them. Communication between the two teams is essential to capture new business and close the deal.

38. Upsell and Renew Existing Clients Through Funnels

You can gain loyal customers by providing an excellent customer experience and maintaining a good customer relationship management strategy. Insurance company services are something individuals and businesses need repeatedly, so constantly marketing to your past clients and nurturing them, whether it’s months or years down the road, can turn them into repeat clients.

39. Monitor and Measure Results Monthly

You could try every one of the insurance marketing strategies here, but the only way to see how they work for you is to monitor and measure your results monthly. There are many ways to do this, such as:

  • Watching sales metrics
  • Monitoring the number of calls/inquiries
  • Measuring the email open rate vs. click rate
  • Paying attention to your email unsubscribe rate
  • Monitor your social media analytics, including likes/follows/comments
  • Use Google Analytics or Google Search Console

Which of These Marketing Tips for Insurance Companies Should You Try First?

Simple insurance company marketing tips for small agencies

The key to the best insurance marketing ideas is to go slow. Try several marketing tips at a time and measure your results. You may find that some work great, and others aren’t your cup of tea. Choose the strategies you are most comfortable trying and will use consistently. Any marketing strategy is a slow and steady game. You won’t see results overnight, but with consistency, you may be surprised at how much it grows your insurance firm.

Mistakes To Avoid With These Marketing Tips for Insurance Companies

When implementing the best marketing ideas, there are some key mistakes to avoid:

  • Not hiring a professional: Let the marketing professionals handle your marketing strategy while you focus on running your business. Everyone has something they do well; if marketing isn’t it, let the professionals do it for you.
  • Relying on a single marketing channel: Don’t put all your eggs in one basket. Diversify your marketing strategy to ensure you maximize the return on your investment.
  • Focusing on too many marketing channels: Diversifying too much can make getting each strategy the necessary attention difficult, leaving you with less than desired results.
  • Not tracking results: It’s impossible to tell which marketing strategies work until you track the results and see which provides the greatest return on your investment. The professionals can track them for you, helping you understand what’s working and what isn’t.
  • Not making adjustments to strategy: After reviewing your results, it’s important to adjust, especially the strategies that aren’t providing the desired results. If you don’t, you continue throwing money at tactics that don’t work.
  • Not knowing what the competition is doing: Always watch your competitors. See what they are doing, changing, or not changing so you can make sure you do better than them and capture a larger part of the market share.
  • Not setting definable targets: Setting your SMART goals ensures you know what you’re trying to achieve and how well you’re doing. You can’t measure your progress or understand what is/isn’t working without a target to reach.
  • Ignoring online marketing completely: If your business doesn’t exist online and you don’t use SEO and other marketing strategies to get a larger audience, your competition will get all the business while you sit and wonder what you did wrong. 

Implement These Insurance Marketing Tips With an Expert

These creative marketing ideas are the key to a successful insurance business! But as a busy professional, you likely don’t have enough time to implement and monitor these strategies. Partnering with a rock-solid marketing company with the experience and results to help your company grow is the key to making your marketing strategies work for you.